The Web3 Gaming Graveyard: Why Over 75% of Games Failed in the Past Five Years

The Web3 gaming sector faces a sobering reality: the vast majority of projects never survive their first few years. According to comprehensive research from CoinGecko examining 2,817 blockchain-based games developed between 2018 and 2023, over 75% have either shut down or become completely dormant. This staggering failure rate reveals deep structural challenges within the GameFi ecosystem.

The Data Behind the Collapse

CoinGecko’s analysis, powered by Footprint Analytics blockchain intelligence, classified Web3 games as inactive when their 14-day moving average of active users dropped by 99% or more. The findings paint a bleak picture: approximately 2,127 games out of the initial pool met their end. Since 2018, the average annual failure rate across GameFi projects has hovered around 80.8%—a sign that success remains the exception rather than the rule.

A Tale of Two Markets: Early Hype and Subsequent Decline

The sector’s boom-and-bust cycle tells a clear story. The 2017 launch of CryptoKitties sparked widespread enthusiasm, prompting developers to flood the market with new titles. In 2018 alone, 422 games launched, yet 307 never found sustainable traction, resulting in a 72.7% failure rate. This early inaccessibility to lasting success continued into the following years.

The crypto bear market of 2019-2020 decimated player interest and funding availability. These years saw only 244 new game launches combined, with failure rates exceeding 94% in both years—evidence that the market was ruthlessly filtering out all but the most resilient projects.

A Brief Respite During the Bull Run

The 2021 crypto bull market provided temporary relief. With increased capital and renewed interest, the failure rate for Web3 games dropped to 45.9%, marking the lowest point in the five-year window. Even amid this optimism, however, 339 projects still failed, suggesting that bullish market conditions alone could not guarantee GameFi success.

The landscape shifted dramatically in 2022 when bear market pressures returned with force. That year witnessed the highest failure rate at 107.1%, meaning the number of defunct games actually exceeded the number of new launches. A record 742 Web3 games became inactive—more failures than in any other year on record.

Signs of Potential Stabilization

As the Web3 gaming space moved into 2023, preliminary data suggested emerging stability. Roughly 509 GameFi projects fell inactive at a 70.7% failure rate—a notable improvement from 2022’s peak. CoinGecko researchers theorize this decline signals market maturation, with only more resilient and well-funded projects continuing to launch.

The lessons are clear: over the past five years, Web3 games have struggled to retain players, secure funding, and compete within an increasingly crowded space. Yet the slight decline in recent failure rates offers a glimmer of hope that the ecosystem may be entering a more sustainable phase—one where only the best-positioned projects survive.

#GameFi